Collecting Haven

Collecting Haven Collecting Haven is the perfect place for collectors to gather! We offer a variety of sports memorab

New release-2025-26 O-Pee-Chee NHL blasters and a restock of MLB Select Mega boxes! 🏒⚾️See you until 8pm!
06/05/2026

New release-2025-26 O-Pee-Chee NHL blasters and a restock of MLB Select Mega boxes! 🏒⚾️

See you until 8pm!

New release Pokémon items for Friday (will be limited)! *Moonlite tins (featuring Gengar and Clefable promo cards)*Lumio...
06/05/2026

New release Pokémon items for Friday (will be limited)!

*Moonlite tins (featuring Gengar and Clefable promo cards)

*Lumiose City mini tins

See you from 10-8!

Happy Thursday!! Collection of Pokémon Center Elite Trainer Boxes & collection of PSA slabs in the shop today!
06/04/2026

Happy Thursday!! Collection of Pokémon Center Elite Trainer Boxes & collection of PSA slabs in the shop today!

Few new items today!*2025 NFL Topps Finest hobby boxes*Fanatics Mystery signed basketball *FIFA Cup Hardcover sticker al...
06/03/2026

Few new items today!

*2025 NFL Topps Finest hobby boxes

*Fanatics Mystery signed basketball

*FIFA Cup Hardcover sticker albums

*Hot wheels Formula 1 track

*Hot Wheels Japanese silver series set

*Hot Wheels Mario Glider cars

Also, congrats to Andrew S. & Paisley for being our weekly gift card winners! 🙌

Thank you so much for the birthday wishes, everyone! It was definitely a great day! 🙂Lots of great stuff hitting the she...
06/02/2026

Thank you so much for the birthday wishes, everyone! It was definitely a great day! 🙂

Lots of great stuff hitting the shelves for Wednesday. We have a few slabs, video games, and OP-10 Sleeved packs available, along with a bunch of singles that will be hitting the display cases.

Happy Monday everyone! ☀️ He’s probably going to kill me 😂 but it’s a pretty special day for the guy behind the counter ...
06/01/2026

Happy Monday everyone! ☀️ He’s probably going to kill me 😂 but it’s a pretty special day for the guy behind the counter that puts his heart and soul into Collecting Haven every single day! If you get a chance to stop in today, definitely wish him a very happy birthday! 🎂🥳🎉

Happy Sunday! Last call on PSA-all submissions are due no later than 12:00! Also, just a heads up that the shop might cl...
05/31/2026

Happy Sunday! Last call on PSA-all submissions are due no later than 12:00! Also, just a heads up that the shop might close at 12:50 today so that Jake can be there if our son makes it to the championship game for lacrosse! ❤️🙌 Have a great day everyone! ☀️

Hey all! We have some bummer news. Some of you may have already heard, but PSA is temporarily shutting down their lower ...
05/29/2026

Hey all! We have some bummer news. Some of you may have already heard, but PSA is temporarily shutting down their lower teir services, which results in us for the foreseeable future not being able to offer drop off service until they get caught up on work.

PSA says:

They are backlogged 10 million cards, and the services will only re-open when that number gets down to 5 million cards. They are anticipating 4 months for this to happen.

With that said we are doing one super VERY LAST MINUTE deadline of Sunday May 31st (cards MUST be in by 12pm). This submission will be for sports cards only or TCG 1980 and newer (no vintage at this time).

We will keep you updated on the updates as PSA provides them to us in the future!

Few new products hitting the shelves today! NBA 25-26 Signature Series hobbyMLB 2026 Donruss hobbyMLB 2026 Pro Set hobby...
05/29/2026

Few new products hitting the shelves today!

NBA 25-26 Signature Series hobby
MLB 2026 Donruss hobby
MLB 2026 Pro Set hobby
MLB 2026 Pro Set Jumbo

Also, a handful of Pokémon singles going into display cases!

See you until 8! 🙌

Small restock of Chaos Rising ETB’s and some Mega Zygarde ex boxes!Some singles are also hitting display cases!Finally, ...
05/28/2026

Small restock of Chaos Rising ETB’s and some Mega Zygarde ex boxes!

Some singles are also hitting display cases!

Finally, congrats to Brad M. & Raylei S. for being our weekly gift card winners! 🙌

Address

N474 Eisenhower Drive Suite J
Appleton, WI
54915

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm
Sunday 9am - 2pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Collecting Haven posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share