30/08/2026
California 1988 Cold Case Solved— 32 Years Later, One Palm Print Named Her Suspect
On the Saturday before Thanksgiving in 1988, nine-year-old Micaela Joy Garecht woke up expecting nothing more than an ordinary weekend.
She grabbed her scooter and headed out with her best friend, Katrina Rodriguez. They rode through their Hayward neighborhood, eventually stopping at Rainbow Market to buy Mountain Dew, candy, and beef jerky.
Nothing about that morning seemed dangerous.
Until they walked back outside.
Micaela's scooter was no longer where they had left it.
Someone had moved it several yards across the parking lot, near an unfamiliar vehicle.
To a nine-year-old, it was just something that needed to be retrieved.
Micaela walked toward it.
Katrina watched her friend approach the scooter, bend down, and reach for the handlebars.
Then a man stepped out of the vehicle.
He grabbed Micaela and forced her inside.
Katrina froze.
Within seconds, the car was gone.
Her best friend had vanished in broad daylight.
An emergency call was made, but the first description given to authorities was wrong. That mistake would complicate the investigation during the crucial first days, while police and volunteers launched massive searches throughout Hayward and the surrounding area.
But Micaela was nowhere.
There was no body.
No confirmed sighting.
No traditional crime scene.
And no clear explanation for where the man had taken her.
Investigators did have one thing.
The scooters.
The one Micaela had walked back to retrieve became an important piece of evidence. Detectives collected fingerprints and, most importantly, a partial palm print from the scooter.
In 1988, however, that print could only tell investigators so much.
There was no modern automated system capable of rapidly comparing a partial palm impression against millions of records.
So the evidence was preserved.
And waited.
Years became decades.
Micaela's mother, Sharon, refused to let her daughter's name disappear. Every November 19, her family returned to the area where the kidnapping happened, keeping a ritual of remembrance alive for more than 30 years.
Then technology finally caught up with the evidence.
Investigators ran that old palm print through an updated identification system.
And suddenly, after decades of silence, the evidence produced a name.
David Emery Mish.
What investigators discovered about Mish's background made the old kidnapping look even more disturbing. He was already serving a lengthy prison sentence for another killing committed in Hayward just one year after Micaela disappeared.
And investigators believed he could be connected to other violent crimes in the Bay Area.
But there was still one enormous question.
Micaela's body had never been found.
And although Mish was formally charged decades after the kidnapping, the case against him still had to survive the courtroom.
For Sharon, the discovery brought something she had waited more than three decades to hear—but also forced her to confront the possibility she had spent her entire life trying not to imagine.
What really happened after Micaela was forced into that car?
And could the tiny palm print collected in 1988 finally reveal the truth?
𝑪𝒐𝒏𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒖𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒔𝒕𝒐𝒓𝒚 👇👇