08/10/2024
When speaking with people about design, most lump things into two camps - its either good or its bad.
But I would suggest most lingeres in the grey area - its not bad, but those who care about design would find it distasteful.
The thing that spawned my thoughts on this was the album cover for Magical Mystery Tour by , which is sandwiched by Sgt Pepper and the white album - both lauded as two of the greatest album covers of all time.
But here in the middle was an album so hideous to look at I never took it seriously, despite it containing some of the Beatles best music.
It works as a cover - has the Beatles written on it (in colorful stars), and will protect the vinal, it has the four of them on the cover (dressed as nightmarish walruses) So technically, functionally it ticks all the boxes. -Objective.
But I hate it because I think it looks terrible. - Opinion.
Most of what we talk about with design is really about taste rather than function. are the worst snobs (speaking as a complete design snob myself) but the truth is most people just don't care.
How many times have you seen a laminated in a shop or hospital in that someone has just printed out and blue-tacked to a wall? Why bother with a nice in when this will do the same job?
Coming back to the album cover, I am a big Beatles fan, but as I said at the start of this I never took seriously because it looked terrible to me.
Thats a big problem if you're selling a product or service. Functionally it may be fine, but if it is not suited to your customer's taste, you won't sell it.
Or maybe it will be fine and no one will notice.