24/07/2026
I'm sure everyone knows I use AI in a lot of different ways, including my cartoon version of Kane (shock horror).
But I came across a busy post from Love Carlisle asking whether AI-generated posters put people off using a business.
A lot of the replies made the same complaint. The glossy posters all look alike.
That makes sense when you look at how the tools work.
An image generator learns patterns from a huge amount of existing work, then predicts what fits your request. Give it a loose prompt for a cafe special or craft fair and it tends to drift towards the familiar.
The result is a crowded layout built from familiar fonts, usually finished with the same shiny images.
You can get something different, but somebody still has to define the design. You need to specify the typefaces and colours. You need rules for spacing and photography too, including what the model must avoid.
Most small business owners won’t know how to do all of that.
Why would they?
A cafe owner shouldn’t need to become a designer just to advertise Friday’s special.
They’re trying to get a job done quickly. The trouble is that another glossy AI poster may make the business look exactly like the one down the road.
I’d keep the graphic simple and put the effort into professional photography.
A professional photo shows the actual product and the people behind the business. Nobody else has that photo. It gives a customer something real to judge.
I use AI in my own work. It helps me sort interview material and get a first draft moving. The interview still happens, and any proof has to come from the business.
If somebody is deciding whether to buy from you, show them the real thing.
AI can help make the poster. It shouldn’t make up what you’re selling.
Thanks to Love Carlisle (I'm not sure why it popped on my feed) for starting the discussion. The original post is here:
https://www.facebook.com/LoveCarlisle.uk/posts/pfbid0CcKifCHcwZcEfLgugjHzrau7u8T7JbHrzXHP7mw4QiLDjJ5XieiC228Nhbtw15U4l
Would you rather see a simple graphic with a good photograph of the real business, even if it isn’t as glossy?