05/01/2025
As cybersecurity threats grow more sophisticated, organizations face increasing pressure to ensure their employees are well-prepared to identify and respond to phishing attacks.
Recently, Yarra City Council in Victoria undertook a simulated phishing exercise, sending employees an email offering a holiday e-gift card as a token of appreciation. Instead of a gift card, employees unwrapped a surprise assignment: mandatory ransomware awareness training! While the exercise aimed to educate, it sparked a heated debate about the approach.
On one hand, cybersecurity training like this is critical. Simulations that mimic real-world tactics can be an effective way to teach vigilance in a controlled environment. By using an enticing but deceptive email, the council attempted to prepare its team for the increasingly clever tactics used by cybercriminals.
However, the ex*****on raises valid concerns. Timing the simulation around the holidays—a time when many employees feel financial strain and anticipate seasonal rewards—has been criticized as insensitive. Australian Services Union deputy secretary Zoe Edwards noted that many workers felt humiliated, particularly lower-paid employees who might have been more likely to hope for such a gesture. Instead of festive cheer, they were greeted with a training deadline set for January 3, the first day back for many. Talk about a plot twist!
This situation highlights the fine line between effective training and maintaining employee trust and morale. While the intent to educate and protect is commendable, it’s crucial to approach such simulations with empathy and clear communication. Employees should feel empowered, not tricked or exploited, in the learning process.
At IT First Responder we believe cybersecurity training doesn’t have to be all “bait and switch.” We help organisations implement phishing simulations that balance realism with respect and even a touch of humor (where appropriate). Our goal is to create a culture of awareness without sacrificing trust or morale—no holiday grinch required.
If your organisation is considering a phishing awareness program, let’s chat! We’ll help you keep your team sharp, secure, and (mostly) smiling.
How does your organisation approach cybersecurity training? Let’s discuss!